It is no secret that within the Civil War living history community, some folks are always declaring that other folks ought to improve their impressions and look more like the original Civil War soldiers. For the sake of argument (now in this context, that’s funny!), let’s agree that some folks can and should do a better job of impersonating the soldiers we all so deeply admire. That said, how good should we look? How far is it realistic to go, based upon what we know now about the appearance and conduct of Civil War soldiers? What is the “state-of-the-art” in Civil War living history impressions?

Here at the Gazette, we thought it might be useful to seek out a few folks who have put together superior impressions – folks who can serve as positive role models for us all.

We consulted with some leaders in the community whose opinions on such matters we respect. They nominated some candidates, and we picked the finalists – the gentlemen you will see in a series of photographic essays beginning here.

We are publishing these articles in the hope that they will show what is possible. We know that details of the various impressions can be argued, but we see that as a good thing if it is done in a constructive manner. If these articles inspire some reenactors to improve their impressions, that will be great.

But nobody should feel compelled to do anything; nobody should be subjected to personal criticism for his appearance; and nobody should come on with that haughty more-authentic-than-thou attitude that stirs up so much ill will in our community.

2004, Camp Chase Publishing ©, Marietta, Ohio
All images on this site are the property of Camp Chase Gazette Publishing and others, and may not be reproduced in any form without expressed written permission.